How old and are you sure she isn't deaf?

 out of  found this valuable. Do you find this valuable?    

Do you still have your Lucy and is she doing any better at potty training? I have just now seen your discussion and wanted to make a few suggestions. This has worked for us and maybe you have already tried it but this is what I do. As soon as mine wake up they go outside. I watch them and as soon as they potty I praise them a lot then when they get back inside I immediately give them a treat and praise them again. With schnauzers I have learned that they don't always go to the door and let you know. You have to watch for signs like they will just stand and stare at you or maybe prance back and forth or go around in circles. After a nap or if they have been playing extra hard they need to go outside and once again give them the treat and praise. After they have learned that this is a good thing to go outside to potty then you can slack off on the treats or if you want to continue the treats you can. You can also hang a bell on the door and have her touch it with her paw each time she goes outside. Sometimes they will learn to hit the bell when they want to go outside. I still have an occasional accident to clean up but that is because I was busy and didn't pay attention to them. I have 14 schnauzers in our house so sometimes that happens. I have learned that praise is a better teacher that punishment. I know it is discouraging sometimes but be patient and give her lots of love and you will be so happy with her once she learns to potty outside. Schnauzers are so lovable and sweet. I wish you the best with Lucy!...... Have a wonderful day!....Monica and . If you would like to reach me here is my website www.snuggleschnauzers.com

 out of  found this valuable. Do you find this valuable?    

They are cool dogs! You should create a page for Max with picture so we can all see him!

 out of  found this valuable. Do you find this valuable?