The Dog WhispererThis is a featured page

Cesar Millan: The Dog Whisperer

Cesar Millan, The Dog WhispererIf you're like our family, you borrowed or bought a number of different books on how to train your new puppy, perhaps went to puppy kindergarten (or some other organized socialization setting), and maybe even hired a trainer or attended a group class to train the dog (um, I mean, to train you).

It was about this time we stumbled upon a show on the National Geographic Channel called The Dog Whisperer. We thought it was a gimmick, but after just two episodes it became clear that this was one clear way to understand dogs, and more importantly, understand dogs and humans.

The titular "dog whisperer," Cesar Millan, who has also been dubbed the "Dr. Phil for dogs," is not only gifted in "reading" dogs (he doesn't really whisper to them, he listens to them), he seems as if he can act like a dog -- more specifically, as the leader of the dog pack. Millan, a native of Culiacan, Mexico, who now calls Los Angeles home, has studied the dynamics of canine pack behavior for years, evolving his "Power of the Pack" owner-dominance training methodology with ultimate respect for dogs and a healthy dose of spiritual perspective. He holds that a positive, fulfilling relationship with your dog is best created and maintained by following the mantra: "Never work against Mother Nature."

The Dog Whisperer showcases the efficacy of his training methods -- his work with adult dogs, including some condemned to be destroyed because of their aggression, is so remarkable that you will suspect that it has been staged. Over and over again, dog behavior and attitude is transformed in minutes. While we struggle to train our dogs over weeks and months (years?).

There are two big pluses to watching 10 to 15 episodes of his show... First, you get to see video of techniques you may have read about in books, or seen in a series of photos. Watching the video (including slo-motion and repeats) is truly helpful. Second, you can get some perspective into what might be sabotaging your training techniques... don't be too surprised when you discover the culprit is you and your attitude. Truly inspiring!

Millan bundled the wisdom of his owner-training/dog-rehabilitation philosophy and technique into the training guide Cesar's Way: The Natural, Everyday Guide to Understanding and Correcting Common Dog Problems, released in 2006.

Tactics inhumane?

Millan's training methodology is premised on achieving calm-assertive dominance over the dog, leveraging pack mentality and dynamics to create a natural social unit of order that places the human in the "alpha" role of pack leader. Some tactics he employs have come under fire (e.g. aversive techniques -- to name a few, leash jerks, kicks, snaps against the neck, restraint -- that result, detractors say, in an unnecessary state of learned helplessness) by professional animal trainers and behaviorists, who decry his dominance theory training tenets as "inhumane." (Read this entry on New Yorker writer Malcolm Gladwell's site for a shortcut delineation of the opposing viewpoints.)

As with all family choices, a dog owner must choose what training techniques to employ to get the kind of lasting behavioral results he or she desires.






  • For information about the concerns some professional dog trainers have raised about Millan's techniques, visit the 4Paws University Dog Training website.



Fans of the show will want to know that the new season of The Dog Whisperer begins Monday, October 23 at 9 p.m. ET/PT on the National Geographic Channel.



Posted Anonymously Latest page update: made by Anonymous , Apr 5 2007, 6:54 PM EDT (about this update About This Update Posted Anonymously Edited anonymously

10 words deleted

view changes

- complete history)
More Info: links to this page
Started By Thread Subject Replies Last Post
ally4dogs Behaviorist vs. Trainer 2 Sep 11 2008, 6:18 PM EDT by meyati
Thread started: Aug 26 2008, 12:27 PM EDT  Watch
I've heard that there is a definite difference between a trainer and a behaviorist. I have been having difficulty with my dogs mostly with interactions with other dogs and when people coming to the door (over excitement). The problem is that when over-stimulated my JRT turns on my other dogs. I have not been able to control this behavior myself despite several attempts and so now need to hire a trainer/behavioralist. I've been told a behaviorist's techniques are much more long-lasting.
1  out of 1 found this valuable. Do you?    
Keyword tags: None
Show Last Reply
Anonymous Cesar's ways are OLD FASHIONED 0 Oct 4 2007, 2:22 PM EDT by Anonymous
 
Thread started: Oct 4 2007, 2:22 PM EDT  Watch
Based on the old-fashioned compulsion methods started by military trainers 40 years ago, Cesar's methods of dominating a dog into compliance are actually quite unenjoyable for our dogs. Modern motivational methods of balanced positive reinforcement with appropriate corrections teach a dog reliability and enjoyment from training.
And it's not really even about humane-ness. It's about effectiveness. There are more effective ways- easier, efficient too!
Yes, pack structure is important -but is actually achieved by our human psychological advantage, not a choke collar. Anyone can go choke and scare a dog into submission. Don't be confused by the "calmness" part. Enjoyment and calmness go hand in hand. Fear can't fit into that equation.

Cesar's mystical words of balance and energy can't stand against the scientific methods researched by animal behavior pioneers such as B.F. Skiner, Pavlov, Karen Pryor and Ian Dunbar. Think twice before "whispering" to your dog. Take a couple minutes to look up "operant and classical conditioning", "marker/clicker training", "animal learning theory". Then you'll begin to understand your dog's mind.
Alison- Canine Command Trainer. www.caninecommand.com
0  out of 3 found this valuable. Do you?    
Keyword tags: None
Anonymous Check out Bark Busters Home Dog Training www.barkbusters.com 0 Jun 30 2007, 10:10 AM EDT by Anonymous
 
Thread started: Jun 30 2007, 10:10 AM EDT  Watch
Known as horse whispering for Dogs, in Australia, check out the world's largest, most trusted, and most referred dog training company, Bark Busters Home Dog Training. What makes this company unique, is that they come to your come and train you how to work with your dog, in a way the dog understands. It's more training the people than the dog. They are world-wide, and offer a life of the dog guarantee. I've used them, they use humane pet-friendly methods, and turned my dog around in a matter of hours.
3  out of 4 found this valuable. Do you?    
Keyword tags: None
Showing 3 of 15 threads for this page - view all

Related Content

  (what's this?Related ContentThanks to keyword tags, links to related pages and threads are added to the bottom of your pages. Up to 15 links are shown, determined by matching tags and by how recently the content was updated; keeping the most current at the top. Share your feedback on Wetpaint Central.)